Skip to main content

In depth Interviews and being present

How does one conduct an in-depth interview without becoming emotionally moved by the powerful narrative unfolding before him/her? One must be a rock or an automaton to remain unaffected. I am all flesh, unfortunately. I try practicing being present, breathing and channeling love towards my interviewee throughout the process. I hope to make them understand that I am trustworthy and will handle their story with care and love.

Yeah, is using love for research purposes a valid academic practice? Enter feminism. It is undeniable that, consciousness raising affects both the interviewer and the interviewee. I can think of three valid scenarios where this can be proven.

Acknowledgement of reality

Women's lives are real, acknowledging that she lived in a rural community, had children, laboured in a plantation and raised her family is reality, as far as I am concerned. It is also but one experience which contributes to a larger narrative. When she tells her-story, she re-creates her narrative by exercising authorship over her experiences. When she creates, she affects collective reality which then must include her reality. The interviewer bears testimony for the act of creation which also impacts his/her reality.

Empowerment of the interviewee

I remember interviewing one woman who told me that it was the first time anyone had ever asked her opinion about something. She had spoken at length of her fear of speaking in a general assembly(the platform for cooperative members to raise questions to the management). She was afraid of seeming foolish and ignorant so she never spoke up. One of the things which always rankled her mind was a  question was about poor performance of the cooperative and how their yearly dividends had started to dwindle. We assured her that it was a valid concern which should be addressed by the management of the cooperative, however she felt she would not have been taken seriously. It was an immense effort for her to communicate her thoughts to us. We listened to her, affirmed her beliefs and assured her that it was necessary for her to speak up. 

Emotional catharsis

I have also observed women going through an emotional catharsis when they speak about painful experiences. One interviewee spoke about her deep ambivalence being abandoned by her abusive husband. She spoke about how he had refused to accept her pregnancy which led her to several attempts to abort her fetus which did not succeed. As she spoke, tears flowed and she relived the moment when she felt completely alone. At that point, I could only channel love and acceptance, allowing her to release her pain within a loving space. Later she mentioned, that her decision to carry on the pregnancy was the will of God. The child grew up to be her pride and joy which she acknowledges is God's work.

It is not possible to overlook or dismiss emotions which arise in the interviews. Emotions of the interviewees must be processed and handled with care. It requires a lot of awareness and sensitivity on the part of interviewer. As much as it is about gathering data, a human subject is complex, unique and awe-inspiring and should be treat with utmost respect. 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

MAPARBEMPCO

During the 1970's, a land dispute between First Southern Land and the residents of Barangay Mapantig occurred. First Southern Land occupied all available tracts of land to the consternation of the residents of the area. People were driven away from their farms and some were even taken to court and imprisoned. Upon facing serious resistance from the company, the villagers gave up and some even moved to different locales in order to survive when the land was taken from them.  When the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform programme was implemented during the presidency of Corazon Aquino, the villagers saw an opportunity arising to get back their land.  However, the company applied for a deferment of 10 years which delayed further the implementation of the land reform programme. Finally in 1998, the Department of Agriculture decreed that the land being occupied by the Kenram Estate (the name of the plantation) would be subjected to agrarian reform. The residents who w...

Giant Slayers - Asian Agri vs. Serikat Buruh Sejahtera Indonesia 1992

PT Andalas IntiAgro Lestari I surveyed this plantation yesterday which is located in Aek Kuo, Labuhanbatu Utara. It is part of the plantations under Asian Agri (Oil Palm Producer) in North Sumatra. There about 400 workers employed in this plantation, non-management staff. There are various tasks done by workers, harvesting, spraying, fertilizing and general work. Women work as daily wage workers or as 'buruh harian lepas' as they are known here. They earn IDR 61,000 per day ( RM19.29) working from 6.30 am to 1.30 pm. They carry out a range of tasks - spraying (semprot), segregation fertilizer (menguntil), weeding, census taking, maintenance and fertilizing (memupuk).  Women's participation Women are recruited by the management of the plantation but not as permanent workers with benefits. These women's husbands work on the plantation and are permanent workers or 'SKU'. The work tasked to women is part of the plantation's production. Some ...

Learning to Mentor

Background I had a wonderful opportunity to attend a useful workshop organized by the Malaysian Institute of Management (MIM) in collaboration with Konrad Adenauer Stiftung (KAS). The workshop was entitled 'Women Mentoring Development Programme' was attended by over 40 women from various fields: civil society, small and medium level entrepreneurs, training and education.  The training was conducted in English by two master trainers who have had experience in mentoring women entrepreneurs. They presented a comprehensive workshop structure which included personal mastery, skills mastery and process mastery. We started with discovering our basic personality attributes to understand our prominent characteristics. We were introduced to a local developed personality assessment tool the LEONARD Personality Inventory. It was quite interesting to discover one's strength and shortcomings based on the analysis.  I am going to highlight some of the elements of the worksh...