Skip to main content

Two Faces of the Same Coin

I have come to the tail end of the household surveys in Mapantig-Kenram. It was a physically exhausting but an extremely rewarding. Listening to women's stories, observing their courageous faces, marveling their strength and fortitude and understanding their lives really made me feel privileged. I thank the universe which made this dream possible. I attest to the strength and beauty of women in this world, without whom it would cease to exist. 


I had an able and reliable friend who patiently held my hand throughout the interviews. She was patient, attentive and involved. I respect her humbleness and ability to include me effectively in the process. I would not have been able to complete this without Zen's steady hands and kind treatment. I learnt a lot from her and developed mutual respect for her local knowledge and passion to serve her community. 

Zenia in orange top
Benevolent dictators and tyrants 

Yesterday was a particularly interesting day for me because I witnessed patriarchy manifest in the husbands' of two respondents. They are from the same community and religious denomination. Today, we had decided to gather respondents in one area for expediency sake and brought them to a gazebo like structure where the women could sit down in the shade and talk to us. This was behind a sari-sari store which obstructed the visibility of anyone standing behind it.

Respondent L (to protect her identity) has 8 children and works as a loose fruit picker. L got married when she was 15 years old through an arranged marriage. During the interview we learned that the respondent was the first wife of a man who had 3 other wives. She was supporting her family with minimal input from him. However, he controlled most of the important resources which was necessary for the family. He was the co-op member who had the benefits such as co-op store credit, earnings from dividends and access to loans and subsidies.  

She had an income which did not exceed P 1000 - 1500 a month and she is currently the main bread winner for her family. Without our knowledge, L's husband had sneaked in to eavesdrop on the interview as it was progressing. We noticed that her voice had reduced to a mere whisper and her reluctance to share had become apparent. Zen realized what the matter was when she saw L's husband. He had been hiding behind the sari-sari store. Although, the interview had not ended, he walked in at the point we were wrapping up. As a token of my appreciation, I usually give the women a brooch for their participation. I usually have a few brooches pinned to a cardboard and ask them to choose their favourite colour. I had asked her to choose her favourite colour when he hovered close behind her and issued an order, "Just choose one!". She submissively picked one up without really looking at it and hurried away. Most respondents would take their time to choose a colour they fancied, but this was not the case with L. She meekly climbed onto his bike and they sped away in a cloud of dust. I was seething with anger and frustration at what had just happened. 

Respondent S's situation was a little more encouraging, though not really better. Her husband was the benevolent dictator, when I first walked into their house. He was busy washing a pile of clothes which he left half way to assist in translating for his wife who only spoke a dialect called Magindanaoan. She was a shy and soft spoken woman who seemed amused by the entire process. The husband was supposed to consult the wife for her answers and let us know what her opinion was to our questions. Though, Zen was my translator, she did not understand this particular dialect. I have been very lucky that Zen could handle Cebuano, Tagalog and Illongo. This was the first respondent who stumped us. However, we were glad the husband could help. After going through basic details, we started on the opinion questions which he answered without even referring to her! I quickly scribbled the comment "husband hijacked the interview". We had to proceed because we did not want to offend, though it seemed like they shared household chores equally, it was clear who was in charge. 

He was a religious authority of sorts and out of the blue, the interview started revolving around him. He was very proud of his role as a provincial expert on religion and started dropping names to us. The clincher was when he offered to read the holy book for us to show us his prowess. We politely agreed and he was very good at it. However, I just suddenly felt I lost this woman due to my lack of ability to control the situation which made me seethe with frustration. Two strikes in a row! It was however an amazing insight into the lives of women whose voices, bodies and thoughts are controlled by men. Both culture and religion were used to advantage men and privilege them, silencing the women effectively. It is beginning to look like a trend in this community. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

MAPARBEMPCO

During the 1970's, a land dispute between First Southern Land and the residents of Barangay Mapantig occurred. First Southern Land occupied all available tracts of land to the consternation of the residents of the area. People were driven away from their farms and some were even taken to court and imprisoned. Upon facing serious resistance from the company, the villagers gave up and some even moved to different locales in order to survive when the land was taken from them.  When the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform programme was implemented during the presidency of Corazon Aquino, the villagers saw an opportunity arising to get back their land.  However, the company applied for a deferment of 10 years which delayed further the implementation of the land reform programme. Finally in 1998, the Department of Agriculture decreed that the land being occupied by the Kenram Estate (the name of the plantation) would be subjected to agrarian reform. The residents who w...

Day 2: Manila (Katipunan)

Well, Day 1 was sleep, eat and find more edibles. Curry withdrawal syndrome has led to a voracious appetite for all sorts of contraband.  Seafood pancit which some gooey noodles. I made a lousy choice and ended up with something I will NEVER try again. Day 2 was super optimistic and lived up to its promise. Met the wonderful Miss Shyl Sales who is effiencient and resourceful, administrative wonder at IPC. I will be taking her for coffee later. She was kind enough to show me a directory of all the work which has been produced by the Institute of Philippines Culture (Ateneo de Manila University). The researchers there are so prolific and do such seminal work. I managed to pick up a great book by Jeanne Frances I.Illo & Cecile C. Uy "Members But Not Leaders - Finding a Niche for Women in Cooperatives". Met the director the amazing Dr. Czarina Saloma-Akpedonu - powerhouse of brilliance and very approachable. She was surprised to know that oil palm plantations existed in ...

Selecting respondents

I had not really given thought to the actual breakdown respondents to be interviewed until I worked through the different types of women I wished to capture in this study. It is a very complex situation as there are:-   1.      Women who are members in the cooperatives . This is the tricky part because my research is about women workers in oil palm plantations but in the case of cooperatives, women collectively own the plantation. They make up part of the general assembly which dictates the running of the plantation. They own the capital collectively and  make decisions collectively. The distinction is great between cooperatives and multi-national corporations. Cooperatives do not have huge amounts capital and resources at their disposal. Alternatively, I can expand the idea of women's involvement in the industry to include cooperative membership of women. This model is more empowering where women are given larger roles and not merely exploited for...